Liberals of India, Unite!
By Abheek Bhattacharya | THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
ASIA | 25 September 2008
Source: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122228833008372349.html?mod=googlenews_wsj
Growing up in a land famous for a rural collectivist
(Mohandas Gandhi) and a Fabian socialist (Jawaharlal
Nehru), I rarely encountered disagreement with the
"obvious" notion that government was the
answer to our nation's problems. The prospect of a
classical liberal movement gaining popularity in India
any time soon seemed dim. Then, this summer I joined
an email list of Indians who discuss public policy
and discovered myself in the company of more than
70 individuals with classical liberal convictions.
Which begged the question: In this country of 1.1.
billion, how many more such liberals are there?
The burgeoning classical liberal movement is feeding
off India's economic growth. The Big Bang liberalization
of the 1990s has already helped realign the middle
class toward the idea of limited government. Thanks
to these 350 million Indians, "the chances of
success of a classical liberal movement are good,"
says Gurcharan Das, who has been advocating liberal
ideas in his Times of India column for 15 years. More
people are coming to disfavor big government thanks
to their own experiences.
Leading the charge are writers and activists such
as Mr. Das who believe India needs more freedom, and
have set out to persuade others. The country has already
seen two winners of the Frederic Bastiat Prize, awarded
annually since 2002 for commentary in vein of the
eponymous 19th-century French thinker.
These new-age commentators are riding the wave of
another effect of India's liberalization, a boom in
technology and communications. More media outlets,
eager to outdo competitors, are listening to diverse
opinions. The Internet is often the delivery system.
Amit Varma, a former columnist for the daily Mint
and the 2007 Bastiat winner, runs a blog that is visited
daily by 10,000 people. Many are likely India's largest
demographic, the youth. Thanks to the Internet, "the
generation growing up today is far more open and broad-minded,"
he says.
The leaders of the movement are already capitalizing
on this generation. The Center for Civil Society,
a libertarian-leaning think tank in New Delhi, actively
recruits college-age youth. Through heavy advertising
at 3,000 colleges across the country, CCS attracts
250 applicants for each of its bi-monthly seminars.
In programs modeled after the libertarian Institute
for Humane Studies in Washington, D.C., students are
exposed -- most for the first time ever -- to the
writings of stalwarts like Bastiat and Friedrich Hayek,
as well as a fresh approach to public policy.
"It was a paradigm shift in thought," says
Dhanu Raj, who hails from southern Cochin city and
attended a CCS seminar in 2003. "We had all found
something new and different," he says. In 2004,
he founded a libertarian institute in Cochin that
conducts national- and local-level research. In November,
Mr. Raj will help host the Liberal Youth South Asia
network, a 100-person youth conference dedicated to
libertarian policy.
In 10 years, CCS has already racked up an impressive
outreach record. Its alumni have founded, among other
organizations, a non-profit in Mumbai in 2003 to tackle
local governance issues and a national forum in December
to conduct outreach seminars in six mid-level cities.
"Our student seminars help in recruiting and
training for grassroots campaigns," says CCS
President Parth Shah. This domino effect is even trickling
down to rural India.
CCS alumni and staff have led rural campaigns on
issues like education choice in states as far flung
as Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh. Their efforts have
started bearing fruit; this year, state governments
in Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh approved school voucher
initiatives. Another classical liberal group, the
Gujarat-based Action Research in Community Health
and Development which publishes a bi-monthly magazine
called Khoj, has been at the forefront of property
rights disputes, most notably at a hydroelectric project
in Gujarat. Thanks to its lobbying efforts, New Delhi
in January awarded property rights to tribal groups
across the country.
India's appetite for industrialization has generated
many land disputes in recent months, most recently
at the Tata Motors factory in Singur, West Bengal
last month. Many farmers, whose land has been appropriated
by the government, are beginning to realize that property
rights can help them. Barun Mitra, who heads up another
Delhi-based libertarian think tank, the Liberty Institute,
says that "land protests are the single biggest
recent event" that can galvanize a liberal movement.
Both the Liberty Institute and CCS work hard at persuading
not just ordinary farmers but policy makers in government
as well. Both organizations regularly publish research
papers, conduct lectures and host "policy breakfasts"
to reach politicians and bureaucrats. Mr. Mitra says
he was surprised to find that "there are many
politicians who are sympathetic to reform, because
of the potential political opportunities." The
trick is reaching the right political threshold.
With a new regional political party in the southern
state of Andhra Pradesh, that may not be far away.
Lok Satta, which registered as a party in 2006, has
to its credit policy changes in key local issues such
as voter registration and rural health. Jayaprakash
Narayan, its founder, is a politician who understands
free markets. "We believe that there must be
a clear demarcation of the role between the state
and the market," he says.
Yet, despite the presence of a liberal party on the
political landscape, it's still too early to sound
the death knell for big government in India. In a
state by-election in March, Lok Satta garnered only
13% of the vote, a reminder that making the invisible
hand visible to voters is never easy. The movement
still has to overcome significant obstacles. For one,
CCS and the Liberty Institute can't do it alone. "We
need eight or more think tanks, working in regional
Indian languages, for research and advocacy,"
says Mr. Shah.
The road away from serfdom may be longer than the
road to it, but with the strides made so far, it's
not impossible to traverse. For the classical liberal
movement in India, there is only room to grow. As
for big government in New Delhi, its days are numbered.
|